Huh, could have sworn I'd posted here about Best Novella already, and I guess not? Well, that and Best Short Story will have to wait until tomorrow or sometime afterwards, 'cause I'm going to bed after I post this.
Besides, this is the strongest category of any of the four primary fiction categories, so hey, you luck out tonight, and maybe you'll have an easier time choosing a top story than I did; I keep switching between my first two choices. Anyway, I've added links to read the stories that are available online, and I hope you enjoy them as much as I did.
"The Only Harmless Great Thing," Brooke BolanderBolander can be hit or miss for me, but this one was a hit: a bittersweet alternate history story in which humans and elephants can communicate – yet the US still uses elephants in pre-nuclear weapons radium experiments. The modern framing device in the story didn’t work quite as well for me, but the relationship between Topsy the rebellious elephant and her trainer, a young woman rapidly decaying from radiation poisoning, was compelling right up to the end. Four stars.
"If at First You Don’t Succeed, Try, Try Again," Zen ChoGoddammit, how is everything in this category so good? This starts off as a folk tale in which an imugi, a mythological Korean creature, tries to ascend to become a dragon. And tries. And tries. And keeps failing, for thousands of years, until finally it seeks out a human who can help, and eventually falls in love. I’ve read other work of Zen Cho’s in
Uncanny and always liked it, and this is no exception. Five stars.
"The Last Banquet of Temporal Confections," Tina ConnollyThis ticked a lot of my favorite boxes: detailed food and flavor discussion! Slow burn storytelling! Memory! Revenge! A solid four stars.
"Nine Last Days on Planet Earth," Daryl GregoryOkay, well, I was going to give “The Thing About Ghost Stories” my top pick, and then this swooped in with its beautifully characterized prose and a story about spaceborne invasive plants that slowly but surely wreak famine and havoc across Earth. It’s a little too believable, in fact, but LT is so very human and his relationships so real that the nagging threat of planetary extinction almost felt secondary to the story of one small person trying to understand how our entire ecosystem would shift. Five stars, utterly amazing, can’t believe how good this field is.
"The Thing About Ghost Stories," Naomi KritzerI read this in
Uncanny when it first came out, and it remains one of the best stories I read last year. It’s less SFF than the other entries, but the characterization is so solid, and the speculative fiction aspects so subtle and well-placed, that it easily deserves to be on this list. Five stars.
"When We Were Starless," Simone HellerI kept thinking I’d landed in the middle of a Fourth Doctor-era story; honestly, since this one covers a civilization that’s lost track of its explorational roots and devolved into tribal nomads at war with an implacable force, it would be a nice companion episode to “The Face of Evil.” Unfortunately, I also found it a bit slow, and the worldbuilding too opaque, at least at the beginning. Three stars.
My rankings (at least right now):
1. Nine Last Days on Planet Earth
2. If at First You Don’t Succeed, Try, Try Again
3. The Thing About Ghost Stories
4. The Last Banquet of Temporal Confections
5. The Only Harmless Great Thing
6. When We Were Starless